Sachs Covered Bridge; Adams County, PA

Sachs Covered Bridge; Adams County, PA
Sachs Covered Bridge; Adams County, PA

Monday, August 14, 2017

Some thoughts about illusions

"Yes, I have tricks in my pocket, I have things up my sleeve. But I am the opposite of a stage magician. He gives you illusion that has the appearance of truth. I give you truth in the pleasant disguise of illusion." Tom near the beginning of "The Glass Menagerie" by Tennessee Williams.


on bike path in Madison, Wisconsin, along Old Middleton Road (The first word is Life.)
I wonder what led someone to write this.
When re-watching online today a scene from "Come Back, Little Sheba," I found out that Shirley Booth played the mother, Amanda, in a CBS Playhouse version of "The Glass Menagerie" in 1966. The video was thought to have been lost; however, the unedited video was recently discovered and pieced together to replicate what was originally broadcast. Hal Holbrook played Tom (the son) and Laura (the daughter) was played by Barbara Loden. This was finally re-broadcast exactly fifty years later by TCM on December 8, 2016. 


 Baltimore, lawn in Roland Park neighborhood. I liked the colors of the leaves.
I didn't have time to watch the full version I found online, so I skipped to the part that especially affects me, when Laura learns about the "gentleman caller's" prior commitment. Loden's reaction of pain was visible to the audience but hidden from her mother and brother as she kept her back to them. In what might still be my favorite version, Karen Allen seemed to conceal her feelings more. As I jumped to some other scenes, I realized that maybe I want to wait to watch this with someone else to talk about it. I used to think about that kind of thing more often in the past, of waiting not to do something because I don't want to do it alone. For some reason I had once set aside a documentary by Errol Morris for that even though it wasn't especially meaningful to me. When I finally watched it because UW was screening many of his films, it was very painful for me to realize I was watching alone and I was glad that the theater was dark. 

Many things come to my mind about what the Tom character, who was probably based on Williams, says about illusions.  In The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma Dr. Bessel van der Kolk quotes this favorably: "The greatest sources of our suffering are the lies we tell ourselves" (Dr. Elvin Semrad [former supervisor at Massachusetts Mental Health Center] 2014: 11). But at other times he says that a way to deal with trauma is through imagination. I forget how he reconciles those two ideas. I think I've often used day dreaming of the future as a way to get by, but the dangers are not to take enough action and to fool myself. 

Another thing I'm reminded of is when I returned home from my freshman year in college during the Labor Day weekend and watched some of "Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory" again on some television station.  The Willy Wonka character doesn't seem to completely believe it when he sings "Pure Imagination"--"If you want to view paradise, simply look around and view it."


Baltimore, outside stores along Hartford Road. They were closed, so I couldn't ask anyone about the chalk. 


6 comments:

Ping said...

Thanks for your post! I think most Chinese, including me, once watched a movie named Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, maybe it's another version of Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory?This is a film that conveys more positive energy to audience.

Chuck Ditzler said...

I've still not seen the movie adaptation you're talking about. It's the same title as the children's book by Roald Dahl. One of my elementary school teachers read it aloud to us.

The early 1970s adaptation was a musical that changed the title's emphasis from Charlie to Willy Wonka, who was played by Gene Wilder. He died not long ago. One of the songs in the movie, "The Candy Man," became a top hit when it was covered by Sammy Davis, Jr. My favorite song in the movie, "Pure Imagination," was sung by Gene Wilder.

Can you watch this YouTube clip in China?:

https://youtu.be/r2pt2-F2j2g

Ping said...

Yes, I can watch this clip through the link you provide. Thank you !

Chuck Ditzler said...

You're welcome! What do you think of this song and the scene? As a kid I thought that the chocolate river was fabulous, and I still do.

I forgot that I've sent you links to YouTube before that you could watch in China.

Ping said...

Seems a thoughtful look on the Wonka character's face when he sings "Pure Imagination", but I'm not sure what he is thinking or whether he doesn't believe it. Perhaps more background on this movie story or the character will help to get better understanding, including lyrics of the song. I prefer the music, it's warm, also sense of time (maybe nostalgic). The scene is filled with children's pleasure. No kid can resist chocolate and candy!

Chuck Ditzler said...

My impression from his facial expressions and overall body language is that he is sad and that he is trying to convince himself that what he is singing is true. I guess watching the rest of movie supports this take since he constantly observes major weaknesses in the kids that he knew about in advance.